Posted by: Dave Burrows | April 27, 2010

Battery life on the #HTC #Desire not as good as the #iPhone 3GS

I have been testing out Battery life on the HTC Desire over the past 4 days and have found the device is pretty battery heavy, heavier than the iPhone unfortunately. I suspect that for the most part the Sense UI is eating up power, along with the OLED although it’s supposed to draw less power. Many have commented that they don’t see much power enhancement on OLED devices. Probably the biggest battery drain by far is the almost entirely connected to the cloud over wifi/3g. Although the iPhone is pretty much always connected, I have found that the Desire has been much quicker to notify you of facebook posts and tweets compared with the iPhone. I have had several Twitter conversations over the past 4 days which almost feel like I’m on an IM chat session. For the most part I’ve tried to have the same or similar apps with push notifications on both devices to try and get a good gauge along with having the brightness levels set at roughly the same levels.

I drove yesterday with Google Maps with the full free navigation with street view, the drive lasted 1h 45 mins and starting on a full battery, I reached my destination with 10% battery power remaining and had received a battery low message that I had to cancel just prior to reaching my destination. The HTC Desire was used for nothing other than navigation on the trip without a car charger. Comparing this to the iPhone, I had 30% battery power left, so the desire really does seem to use more battery. Likewise if I’m playing with the device in the day, the battery drains quicker than the iPhone. Comparing the HTC Desire’s 1400 mAh battery vs the iPhone’s 1219 mAh battery rating, you would think the Desire should be able to last longer?

Google maps managed to get me to my destination but I had frequent drop outs in GPS coverage and the TTS voice was way too low to actually hear with the car radio on. Google maps also provided a lot of late turn instructions which meant if I was actually listening to the instructions I would have missed the turn if I didn’t know where I was, and that would have meant I would have never reached my destination because my battery would have drained too much. I’ll write up a google maps navigation post a little later on my experiences.

Advertisement

Responses

  1. When iPhone is connected over WiFi the delivery of push messages can delayed by 15 minutes, to save the power.

    • Thanks, yeah that’s what I was seeing. The Desire was sending tweets over WiFi pretty quickly (almost instant) but the iPhone was lacking behind for the most part for about 30 seconds to 1 minute, but on some occasions it was a good 10-15 mins before I received the push notification. For the most part the Desire always received a tweet or facebook notification before the iPhone. This is probably a good way to conserve a little more power on the iPhone although probably not a lot, but every minute helps :)

  2. try the following: 1) Use a plain wall-paper. 2) Add the Android Power Control Widget to your Home-Screen, so YOU control when apps sync, wi-fi is on, blue-tooth is on etc. You get better results managing it like this. Atleast the Desire you can customize, unlike the nazi that is Apples iphone, who needed a whole new model (3GS) to improve battery issues.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.